MDAA Polski Back To Home

Missile Defense In The News
Bookmark and Share
9/19/2014 - Informational Flow

MDAA Alert: 

Informational Flow  

September 19, 2014

(left to right) Joseph DeAntona, Craig Franklin, Riki Ellison, Archer Macy, Richard Formica

MDAA Roundtable Discussion, Capitol Hill, Washington D.C. 

September 18, 2014 

Dear Members and Friends, 

Yesterday, MDAA hosted and set a precedent in its platform on educational advocacy for missile defense to the American public through their representation in Congress. We attained a unique format of recently retired U.S. missile defense war fighters from the three services involved with missile defense. 

MDAA's format covered the full spectrum of missile defense through our four speakers' presentations and roundtable of questions and discussion. We chose to present missile defense from an operational perspective. The discussion began with a regional and U.S. homeland BMD force provider perspective.  We then moved on to the Joint Staff and strategic planning of missile defense with one of the three architects of the Obama Administration's 2010 Ballistic Missile Defense Review that now serves as the nation's policy on Missile Defense, as well as the U.S. Navy's perspective on the operational use of Aegis BMD. We then went to the operational command of missile defense in the EUCOM Combative Commander's Area of Responsibility including NATO, battle management, communications and command. This led into the final presentation on missile defense from a tactical perspective from CENTCOM which informed on the Gulf Cooperation Council partnerships, THAAD, Patriot and C-RAM. 
MDAA's distinguished panel of speakers were:

Richard Formica
LTG, U.S. Army (Retired)
Former Commander of the U.S. Army Space and Missile Command. Also served as Commander of US Strategic Command's Joint Functional Component Command - Integrated Missile Defense.

Archer Macy
RADM, U.S. Navy (Retired)
Former Director of the Joint Integrated Air and Missile Defense Organization on the Joint Chiefs of Staff.  Previously Commander of the Naval Surface Warfare Center, and Deputy Commander for Combat Systems Engineering, Naval Sea Systems Command

Craig Franklin
MajGen, U.S. Air Force (Retired)
Former Third Air Force/Seventeenth Expeditionary Air Force Command and Formerly Vice Director of the Joint Staff

Joseph DeAntona
COL, U.S. Army (Retired)
Former Commander of the 11th Air Defense Artillery Brigade. Previously Chief of Staff of the 32nd Army Air and Missile Defense Command; Commander of the 2nd BN, 1st ADA (PATRIOT), 35th ADA Brigade and Personnel Proponent Officer, Office of the Chief of Air Defense Artillery



The key points coming from the discussion were:   


1.There is not enough resources to meet the requirements for both regional and homeland defense. Force providers must make difficult trade offs between capability, capacity, testing, and strain on missile defense personnel from extended deployments. 


2. GBI must return to an annual testing cadence.  


3. A third missile defense site would add much needed time and battle space to counter eastward ballistic missile threats, however, in a constrained budget environment, increased testing and reliability of the Ground Based Midcourse Defense must take precedent.


4. The purpose of regional missile defense is to blunt effects of an initial ballistic missile attack, and allows time for offensive forces remove the threat.


5. The key strength of Aegis sea-based missile defenses is the ability to unilaterally locate and relocate missile defense assets to regions as needed. 


6. With current numbers, BMD ships cannot be everywhere we need them all the time. Crews cannot be deployed indefinitely, and cruise times to reach destinations can be long and expensive. The U.S. needs to convert as many ships as possible to be BMD capable, to ensure the fleet is capable of undertaking multi-mission operations across the globe. 


7. Advances in integrated BMD command and control systems will allow for more efficient deployments of Patriot missile systems throughout the world.


8. Working with partners for increased capacity and burden sharing is vital, as it is fiscally impossible for the United States to do everything on its own. However, burden sharing should be done in a way that ensures hardware compatibility between the United States and partner countries. 


9. Deployments of U.S. missile defense assets to partner countries often results in those countries acquiring BMD capabilities of their own. The United Arab Emirates' acquisition of Patriot and Thaad systems is a key example of this trend.


10. Advances in boost-phase missile defense technologies such the Airborne Laser is limited by both physics, and the ability for missile defense systems to get close enough to missile launches to destroy them without being destroyed themselves by enemy defenses. Another key challenge for boost-phase BMD is getting defense assets to the launch area in time, as engagement times during boost-phase is short.

9/19/2014 Informational Flow
9/17/2014 Iron Dome: An Assessment
9/13/2014 Cold Warriors
9/11/2014 A Moment
9/8/2014 The European Situation
8/29/2014 Social Responsibility
8/25/2014 Great Danes
8/24/2014 Breakfast of Champions
8/21/2014 GMD Is Not a Choice, It's an Imperative
8/8/2014 Breaking Video: Riki Ellison on Bloomberg
8/7/2014 O-H-I-O
8/5/2014 Leading From The Front
8/4/2014 Help is on the Way: President Signs Iron Dome Support Package
7/24/2014 Stop the MADness
7/22/2014 Smoking Gun
7/18/2014 Watch: Riki Ellison talks Iron Dome on Fox News
7/10/2014 Breaking Video: Iron Dome in Action
7/3/2014 American and Proud of It
6/22/2014 US Validates New Defense Against North Korea with Successful Intercept
4/7/2014 MDAA Honors European Missile Defenders at Inaugural Ceremony
2/12/2014 VIDEO: Sen. Kelly Ayotte Spotlighted for Missile Defense Advocacy
1/29/2014 Let's be the Best!
1/22/2014 Sky Jumpers to Sky Strikers
1/13/2014 Best of the Best
7/11/2012 "Where East Meets West"
7/11/2012 "Where East Meets West"
4/12/2010 In Memoriam, Lech Kaczynski
2/23/2010 A Tribute
9/28/2009 U.S. Air Force Supports Successful Delta II STSS DEMO Launch